Welcome to New Wayne Pizza
New Wayne Pizza, located at 109 S Wayne Ave in Wayne, PA, is a culinary gem that stands out for its delicious offerings and welcoming atmosphere. Known for its fresh, flavorful pizzas, including the highly praised ultimate upside-down pizza, this eatery is a favorite among locals. Customers rave about the medium-thicker crust, achieving the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. Friendly staff, led by the fabulous cashier Dave, create an inviting experience for diners. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a full pie, New Wayne Pizza promises a satisfying meal that keeps patrons coming back for more.
New Wayne Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Dave, as the cashier, is FABULOUS...he is respectful and kind and so helpful. the food is really fresh and always hot and always delicious. my sons LOVE dining at WAYNE PIZZA
So good. Literally heaven in my mouth. I got the ultimate upside down pizza.
Stopped in for a couple slices on our neighbor's recommendation. Very good pizza, especially if you like a medium - thicker crust. Right amount of crispy and chewy. Pizza was very flavorful, staff was very friendly, upbeat, and they obviously cared about what they were serving. Would definitely go again!
Pizza good, really good. Cheese good Crust so good Toppings good Sauce good Nothing more to say good pizza
Quick and easy walk from the office. The sell by the slice but the slices are small. The crew there was nice enough to up the smaller slices to make full slices. Nice and hot even after walking back to office to each it on a 20 degree day a couple weeks ago. Obviously it was good if I came back to review weeks after the fact. Will stop by again when I'm in the area.
About 20 years ago, this was my go to spot. The food and service was worth the trip. I then moved away. I came back and it seemed like the original owners were gone. I was worried but when I tried the food it was great. The grinders and strombolis are the best anywhere. The pizza is also very good, better than most. The service and staff are always super nice and friendly. They truly make you feel welcome. There is a small dine-in area but it might be better to grab and go. The only downside is the parking situation. If you are running in to grab food, there is temporary parking right out front. Other than that there is street parking down the street and a small lot down the way as well. I do need to try some other things on the menu but I find it hard not to get one of the three items that I always do. I find the food worth the drive. My top go to place.
Guest Eater Evan Benn. I love the Greco family. They could easily be Delaware County’s 1st family of cheesesteaks. The grill person had skills. We got the garlic bread cheesesteak and a mushroom cheesesteak. Both were very good. Every cheesesteak gets toasted, I like that. Both had a lot of their named flavors. I would have liked one more slice of cheese and a better cheese melt. I feel like if I asked for an extra slice of cheese they would have given it to me.
Popped in for a quick slice while on tour with my band. Thick crust (which I don’t usually like) was buttery with crispy edges. Chunky cuts of toppings, not the thin little veggie slices other places give you. And the cheese was thick and stretchy. Service was friendly and generous (thanks for the hookup guys ;) I would definitely recommend this spot for a tasty alternative to the usual thin crust, NY-style slice or pie. (3 stars for ‘atmosphere’ not meant as a dis. It’s just pretty bare bones.. stacks of pizza boxes, take out menus, and a few plain tables. A working pizza kitchen, not a cutesy pizza restaurant)
Location
-
109 S Wayne Ave, Wayne, PA 19087, United States Hotline: +1 610-688-2301
Welcome to New Wayne Pizza, a hidden gem located at 109 S Wayne Ave, Wayne, PA. If you're seeking a delightful pizza experience, you've landed in the right place. This charming establishment is renowned not just for its delicious array of pizzas, but also for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service.
Many visitors rave about the friendly staff, particularly highlighting Dave, the cashier, for his fabulous customer service. Reviews consistently echo sentiments of warmth and respect, making every visit feel special. As Judith M. Krupnick mentions, the food is always fresh, hot, and nothing short of delicious—a promise echoed by families who find solace in dining at New Wayne Pizza.
The menu boasts signature creations like the ‘ultimate upside down pizza,’ which Shehzad Waseem describes as “literally heaven in my mouth.” This distinctive twist on traditional pizza showcases how New Wayne Pizza expertly balances creativity with classic flavors, capturing the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and visitors alike.
Residents and newcomers have praised the medium-thicker crust that offers a perfect combination of crispy and chewy textures. Miles Curtis emphasizes how flavorful the pizza is, making it a go-to spot for anyone in search of quality. That sentiment resonates with Brody Dayton, who succinctly sums up his experience with a simple, “good pizza.”
Whether you're on a quick lunch break, as Daniel Holtzinger notes, or planning a family dinner, New Wayne Pizza caters to all. They offer convenient slices, ensuring you can enjoy their great flavors even on the go. And as you savor each bite, you’ll appreciate how the right balance of cheese, toppings, and sauce crafts a delightful pizza experience.
In conclusion, New Wayne Pizza isn’t just about satisfying hunger—it’s about creating memorable culinary moments. With an emphasis on quality ingredients, warm service, and an inviting atmosphere, it's no wonder this pizza spot quickly becomes a favorite in Wayne, PA. Next time you're in the area, make it a point to stop by and indulge in what many are calling the best pizza around.